Arguments, Values and Baseballs: Representation of Popov v. Hayashi
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper, we model a recent legal case as presented in a court of first instance using argument schemes and an argumentation framework, providing a formal analysis of the case and how the outcome was determined. The paper contributes to the body of literature that formally analyses legal cases in terms of arguments and argument schemes. It is novel in that we analyse a case in a court of first instance, so we have arguments about facts, qualifications of intermediate predicates, and the application of legal rules. We show the importance of undercutters in relating principles to the specific case.
منابع مشابه
Bibliography of Popov v Hayashi in AI and Law
Bibliography for Popov v Hayashi in AI and Law and selected AI and Law papers on the wild animals cases.
متن کاملA Study of the Representation of Actionswith Regard to the Verse 105 of Tawbah
Almighty God, the Prophet (s) and the believers. According to the Shiite religious teachings, human actions are offered on a special day to the Almighty God, the Prophet (s) and the infallible Imams. Sunni scholars also believe that human acts are offered on special days to the Exalted God, the prophets, the fathers, the mothers, and the deads. The present study analyzes the discussion with an ...
متن کاملEffects of throwing overweight and underweight baseballs on throwing velocity and accuracy.
The purpose of this review is to determine how throwing overweight and underweight baseballs affects baseball throwing velocity and accuracy. Two studies examined how a warm-up with overweight baseballs affected throwing velocity and accuracy of 5 oz regulation baseballs. One of these studies showed significant increases in throwing velocity and accuracy, while the other study found no signific...
متن کاملThe Status of Allegory and Symbolic Language in Quranic Stories: A Review and Critique of the Theory of Fantasization
One of the common views in contemporary Quranic research is the dialog on the existence of allegory and symbolic language in the Quran and Quranic stories. Citing such arguments as the common literary style between the Quranic stories and human stories, the use of symbols with specific modes of expression in the Quran and the cases in which the Divine intent is expressed through questions and a...
متن کاملA remark on asymptotic enumeration of highest weights in tensor powers of a representation
We consider the semigroup $S$ of highest weights appearing in tensor powers $V^{otimes k}$ of a finite dimensional representation $V$ of a connected reductive group. We describe the cone generated by $S$ as the cone over the weight polytope of $V$ intersected with the positive Weyl chamber. From this we get a description for the asymptotic of the number of highest weights appearing in $V^{otime...
متن کامل